Share Poetry Critiques Poetry       Forums       Freewrite       Store      

Indian Summer

Indian summer comes late this year
Twisting its fingers around the earth
And coaxing quiet flowers from their hide-aways
They grow
slow at first
then fast
And then winter comes again and
Kills
Them
All

Do you like it? Any critiscm, suggestions?

    : Comment:

Comments


  • Lad silver member
    January 19, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    For me, colin, this is neatly and cleverly written, but it is, after all, prose, not poetry, although it's perhaps prose with a poetic touch. There is, though, a singular image in it, holding the piece together: winter's fingers. Using and extending that anthropomorphic "fingers" again toward the end of the piece might strengthen its poetic possibilities - as in, perhaps:

    Strangles
    Them
    All.

    "Kills" is generic; "Strangles" might be a more precise image for destructive "fingers". I know how reluctant you are to revise, colin, so I offer it as the merest thought.

    Hope all is well. Hang in there, as always!

    Lad


  • skipeople
    January 16, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    umm..this is a hard one. It isn't that I don't like it, but it is too simple for me. I mean simple and straight to the point can be a great thing sometimes, but this just doesn't do it for me. (Not to go all Simon cawl on you) It almost appears like a middle schooler wrote it or what not.

    Maybe you could try adding on top of what you have now. Add more specific things to help it stand out. It is a bit plain and over done.

    I hope I helped...please don't be mad...=} hehehe


    • Colin Night
      January 17, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      Hmm, I get what you mean. It is rather simple, I dont usually write this way, just an experiment.
      Of course I'm not mad! Im open to any constructive critiscm. And your not going all Simon on me. The one time I watched the show, he was my favorite judge. more down to earth then the annoying woman with her dancing and her plastic face.
      Thanks for the comment,
      -Colin