Share Poetry Critiques Poetry       Forums       Freewrite       Store      

The Balcony

An old man sits on his balcony and watches
the comings and goings of others
and their interminglings.
The cacophony of voices float to him
and uplift his loneliness with their chaos;
he sees two young lovers meet with laughter
and he smiles to himself in remembrance of younger days.

For a time, he is complacent; for a time.

The intrusion of gaiety into his somber morning
speaks volumes of whispered images
and a solitary teardrop slips down the bed
of wrinkled softness to hang from his chin unnoticed.
I stand quietly, watching his reverie with empathy
and then slowly move to return his frail body
to the crumpled death-bed of loneliness
where once he shared passioned lifetimes
with the woman who was his wife.

For a time, he was complacent; for a time.

A small sigh escapes his lips and he stares
at the textured plaster ceiling where
shadow and light play duels in little pockets.
He whispers to me as I turn to go-
“I loved her so much, Alan, so much…
I miss her, each moment, every day.”
I tuck the blanket around his neck,
and wipe the liquid trace of sorrow
away with a gentle palm.

A young man sits on his balcony and watches
the comings and goings of others
and their interminglings.
The cacophony of voices float to him
and bring him to loneliness with their chaos;
he sees two young lovers meet with laughter
and he smiles to himself in acceptance of older days.

What can i do to improve this? it is my personal favorite, but seems to lack something that i cannot touch upon. suggestions?

Sorry, you cannot respond to an archived poem

Reviews


  • Kevin Moderators member
    August 9, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    Great prose

    “winds” is frustratingly easy to confuse with the wind that blows.

    the word ‘acknowledgement’ at the end felt weak and too long to me.

    I loved the overall feeling, and passage of time. It tells a nice story, in a beautiful and poetic way, where everything seems just a bit larger than life…

    . Rewarded 4

    • Circuitsboard
      August 9, 2005
      Edit | Reply

      Thanks, Kevin.

      Thanks for taking the time to comment.
      I do agree that “winds” can be confused as you said. I will work on that word choice.
      “Acknowledgement” is quite a long word, so I chose ‘acceptance’ which does seem to fit much better.

      Oh, and congrats on your engagement and wedding. Having been married twice, I wish you the best of luck and I think I can already see you have the commitment to work to make it long and strong.


  • pellucidrockstar
    August 9, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    long.

    i think the ‘concept’, the ‘idea’, is pleasant and carries the potential to imbue poetry with meaning ; but meaning is better delivered efficiently (my opinion) you might find you’re happier with it boiled down.

    . Rewarded 1

    • Circuitsboard
      August 9, 2005
      Edit | Reply

      long?

      Actually, in comparison with many of my favorite poems of some modern and many old poets, this is but a swift read.
      Less is not always more…
      I wrote the first three lines long ago, but could never complete it. Then one night it fell out of my mind in a few minutes. It tells the story I wish to tell, conveying (to me) the emotions I wish it to, in the time frame I wanted it to have.

      As this is supposed to be a site for more serious critiquing, feel free to elaborate on your sense of ‘boiled down’ efficiency. I do have an open mind and will consider your thoughts.

      Thanks for taking time to comment!


  • lordoftherings gold member
    August 10, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    It is too prosaic

    Though I love the idea of a narrative for this type of subject in a poem, I find the work is too prosaic…a lot of prepositions and joining words to produce complete sentences instead of fragmented thoughts. Poetry has to deal with more of the use of using every word in the poem and not just throwing in words to make sure you have a correct English structured phrase. I would get rid of the unnecessary words that do nothing for the poem except make it a very short story and zero in on the key words that will draw the reader to the true emotion of the poem.

    Gregg

    . Rewarded 1

  • Saki
    August 10, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    Excellent Theme

    The message was beautiful. I loved the way you contrasted how similar situations have different effects on two different individuals. It’s so true.

    yeah, I do agree that it was somehow prosaic. I think you need to add music to it.

    . Rewarded 1


  • August 10, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    Moving

    I really wish I could offer some suggestions on this, but I find myself caught up in the simplicity of the images that evoke such emotion. I like the role reversal at the end. I feel for the old man as well. I could actually see the apathetic/dejected look on his face as he looked at the ceiling remembering the past..and knowing it wasn’t there anymore. That basically is good poetry to me.

    . Rewarded 1

  • 5th position Gb
    August 11, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    Very touching

    I really liked how this touched me. I liked the images and choice of words you used (shadow and light play duels in little pockets, liquid trace of sorrow, etc.) I’m not really sure what it was, but it just seemed to me like there was something missing between the last stanza and the one before it. I’m not really sure what it is. It just sort of seemed weird to me. I wish I could help you more, but that’s all I can pull out of my mind at the moment.

  • Paragon Belial
    August 13, 2005
    Edit | Reply
    I really don’t think you should nominate yourself into the spotlight box.

    • Circuitsboard
      August 13, 2005
      Edit | Reply
      Neither do I. I just clicked to see the functionality.
      Sometimes you just gotta be that way…


  • DawnBaby gold member
    August 21, 2005
    Edit | Reply

    Great job....lacks closure

    When I read this I want it to have some ending, it seems to be left without one, leaving the old man in his sorrow and the young man now taking over for his father. I would add one more verse of conclusion. Just my humble opinion, it is a very good write.

    . Rewarded 1


  • abernaith
    August 25, 2005
    Edit | Reply
    I think it was excellent how you wrapped this poem up: the comparison with the young man and the old one was acutely felt in the difference of their small gestures, their ‘little’ opinions. Lines 8 and 18 moves the poem beautifully, makes the imagery flow in a “sunset-sunrise” sort-of way..

    Perhaps, though I am not too sure that we’d agree, what you felt was lacking was the fullness of the younger man’s character. We see him caring for the old man, but other than that, the only role he plays is to wrap up the poem with a comparison of his actions to the old man. There isn’t much said of how he remembers things…and this would have been perfectly acceptable had the focus been completely upon the old man and his melancholy and loneliness. But, you’ve ended making the younger man, “Alan”, the narrator, an integral part of your poem’s subject. Maybe, although your poem already has a very good standing in my books, you could insert more insight into Alan’s character, flesh him out more with his own point of view (other than the one offered in the last line, which is pretty powerful already, used in comparison to the old man’s.)

    . Rewarded 1

  • emma cameron
    November 14, 2005
    Edit | Reply
    I,m at a loss for words that will express how this wonderful poem made me feel(apart from tearful)the old man lonely and tearful for what he had lost the young mans´acceptance of his lonely future.(I think).The words brought vivid scences to my mind and the descriptive passages were beautiful in their imagery.To me it doesn´t lack anything.

    . Rewarded 1